from the West Papua Media investigative team*
February 28, 2013
EXCLUSIVE: Special Investigative Report
Local communities around Sinak, Gurage, Mulia and Tingginambut in
Puncak Jaya
regency have felt the first effects of Indonesian military reprisals,
after West Papuan independence guerrillas under General Goliat Tabuni
confirmed that they had killed eight Indonesian special forces soldiers
and four non-Papuan civilians on February 21 in two separate incidents.
The shootings were carried out after Kopassus officers continued to
build military posts on a local sacred burial site, despite being
requested not to by both community representatives and emissaries from
the West Papua National Liberation Army (
Tentara Pembebasan Nasional Papua Barat – TPN-PB)
under Tabuni. TPN spokespeople have said that the shootings were done
“to assert West Papuan sovereignty against Indonesian colonial
occupation”, and to assert West Papuan cultural rights to defend their
customary practices against ongoing military brutality.
A spokesman for the Goliat Tabuni’s TPN-OPM command, Nikolas Tabuni, told
West Papua Media in a statement that the killings were not without cause.
“Prior to the incident TNI had wanted to make a military post in
the region of Tingginambut and the TPN OPM had sent a letter to the TNI
asking them not to’ go ahead with the military post construction at
Tingginambut. As that is an area of which the land is formally claimed
to be owned by the TPN OPM, and as it is also a sacred area under
indigenous customary law of the indigenous community of that area.
However TNI disregarded the request (in principle) and continued with
the construction. As a result TPN OPM carried out the shooting on 21
February,” the statement read.
Nikolas Tabuni also denied statements from the Indonesian President
and Police that the shootings were connected with Indonesian election
campaigns in Papua. “This shooting had absolutely nothing to do with
the election of the Bupati (Regency leader) for the region of Ilaga in
the Regency of Puncak Jaya in the Province of Papua, and had nothing to
do with the general election of the Provincial Governor. The shooting
was purely concerned with Papuan independence and the activities of the
TNI in West Papua.”
Evidence of collective punishment emerges
Despite an effective information blockade imposed by thousands of
Indonesian army (TNI) troops and Police, and unchallenged by a compliant
Jakarta-based colonial media, detailed reports are beginning to filter
through from independent sources in the area of the military offensive,
painting a vastly different picture to that reported by Indonesian and
international media since the shooting of the Kopassus soldiers.
TNI soldiers manning checkpoint near Sinak, Puncak Jaya (Photo: jpnn.com/ malanesia.com)
At least 1000 members of various Indonesian security forces are
currently occupying and laying siege to entire communities around Puncak
Jaya, with thousands more troops being sent in from other centres in
Papua, according to local church, human rights, and sources in contact
with
West Papua Media stringers across the conflict area.
TNI 753 Btn interrogating locals in Sinak (photo: Malanesia.com)
According to these sources, the villages of Tingginambut, Trugi and
Nelekom have been occupied by TNI forces since Sunday February 24, with
villagers being forced to give all their food and houses to soldiers,
and being subject to arbitrary and harsh interrogations. TPN sources
have also stated that troops are using the villages as strategic hamlets
to prepare for a hunt and destroy mission to flush out the forces of
Tabuni, who have claimed they are well prepared for guerrilla defence.
In Nambut and Gurake (Gurage) villages in Sinak District, security
forces began to carry out house to house sweeping operations on February
26, and in villages in Tingginambut, Puncak Jaya. According to our
sources, the TNI Commander in the area has commanded “that the sweeping
operation is to be continued until the culprits from last Thursdays
killings are arrested”. The TNI have stated to local people they “need
to see 11 persons sentenced,” according to the reliable source.
Two civilians were said to be arrested on February 27, according to
Indonesian military reports, however independent sources could not
confirm if any other civilians have been arrested.
As of February 26, at least 18 houses have been burned to the ground,
5 GIDI churches razed, 2 schools and a library have been destroyed by
the combined Police/TNI forces in Tingginambut, according to reliable
church sources who have safely relayed data from witnesses to
West Papua Media
stringers. Witnesses have also reported that soldiers are
deliberately burning and destroying food gardens and shooting livestock,
including over one hundred pigs. There are fears of a major
humanitarian disaster unfolding with the reports of the destruction of
food gardens and livestock, an act of collective punishment on a
civilian population.
Thousands of people from the surrounding villages have fled to the
high mountains and according to church sources, the entire community
populations have fled throughout the area of Gurake, Sinak, Tinggi Neri,
Trugi and Nelekom. Exact numbers are not currently known but local
sources indicate that several thousand people, mainly subsistence
farmers, live in the area.
Human rights workers have also reported from Mulia in Puncak Jaya
that townspeople are greeting news of the offensive with panic and
preparing to flee.
Reports are difficult to verify as the only media personnel allowed
into the operations area are those with approval from the Indonesian
army, and very few of these journalist have actually ventured into the
area. Stringers for
West Papua Media in Puncak Jaya and the
Baliem Valley have reported that independent journalists and human
rights workers have been prevented from travelling into the area by a de
facto
Military Operations Area being applied across the entire highlands, including the regional centre of Wamena.
Civilians are staying off the streets as reliable local sources
report a massive combat army and police show of force, including house
to house searches. On the morning of February 28, witnesses have
reported to
West Papua Media stringers that 8 Brimob trucks have left
Troops patrolling Wamena – February 25 (photo: supplied)
Wamena heading to Puncak Jaya this morning, with large numbers of troops patrolling the streets across Wamena also..
Thousands more troops flooding in to attempt to destroy Tabuni’s TPN.
Thousands of heavily armed combat soldiers from Battalions 751
(Jayapura), 753 (Nabire) , and supported by the Wamena 756 Batallion,
are reportedly being flown into Tingginambut over the next few days from
several centres across Papua. They are joining together with over 1000
extra Brimob paramilitary police (in addition to the at least 1000
Polda Papua police already in the highlands), and allegedly several
units of the notorious Australian-funded Detachment 88 anti-terror
commando, to hunt for Tabuni’s forces. Several media reports in
Indonesia are also claiming a Kostrad (Strategic Reserve) battalion is
being deployed from outside Papua, though this has not been
independently confirmed.
Local sources have reported that each TNI platoon is accompanied by a
platoon of police, as the operation is officially under control of the
Police as a “law enforcement” operation. However, the witnesses have
reported that the TNI are clearly in command. TNI spokespeople in
Jakarta have told Indonesian media outlets that there is no plan to
increase non-organic troop presence in the area, but local sources are
reporting a vastly different story.
West Papua Media sources in Wamena observing the airport
have confirmed that two TNI Puma Helicopters are involved in the
operation constantly ferrying troops between Wamena and Tingginambut,
and stopping only for refuelling and crew changes. Three Hercules c130H
aircraft have each made 3 drops to Wamena then the troops have entered
by road from Wamena. Observers in Nabire have also noted daily
departures of three trucks of troops from the notorious Battalion 753
Nabire, to the west of the highlands to reinforce the offensive in
Tingginambut.
Human rights and church sources in Puncak Jaya and internationally
have expressed deep concern about the potential for heavy civilian
casualties to occur with the intensified military campaign, given extra
impetus after the Indonesian President, General Susilo Bambang
Yudoyhono, called for firm action on Tabuni.
Multiple narratives from Jakarta
The exact circumstances of the deaths of the eight Kopassus special
forces soldiers are now mired in claim and counter-claim, with soldiers’
personal accounts of the attack conflicting with the official narrative
picked up by Jakarta media. What is confirmed is that the eight
commandos – Sertu (Chief Sergeant) Udine, Sertu Frans, Sertu Romadhon,
Pratu (Private 1st class) Mustofa, Sertu Edy, Praka (Chief Private)
Jojon, Praka Wempi and Sertu Mudin – were killed by a cascading attack
led by guerrillas of Goliat Tabuni’s TPN group as they went to the Sinak
airstrip to collect cellular monitoring equipment designed to track
international phone communications in the area.
However, one survivor of the attack testified in the
Jakarta Post
that his group was attacked by men, women and children all carrying
spears, machetes and knives. According to the TNI survivors as relayed
to JP, the platoon of Kopassus was unarmed at the time of the attack,
which happened as the soldiers were installing and moving communications
monitoring equipment.
Troops in Tingginambut after being shot at in helicopter by TPN, Feb 21 (Photo: TNI)
TPN forces also opened fire on a Puma helicopter that was evacuating
the wounded commandos, lightly injuring three helicopter crew.
West Papua Media sources have provided a highly credible and
technical but unconfirmed report that two “very large weapons” that
were being moved into Sinak, and went missing during the raid by TPN.
According to our sources, there is “extreme concern from the TNI around
this particular issue.”
“Apparently they have been trying to find out the whereabouts of
these weapons, which suggests they might be too heavy to quickly and
easily move,” explained the source. Further investigation is still
required, but credible observers in the area believe that these heavy
weapons may be artillery pieces – the presence of which in Puncak Jaya
represents a serious and dangerous escalation of TNI hardware to be used
against civilians.
West Papua Media believes any confirmed
presence of artillery is connected with the TNI’s stated aim to destroy
Goliat Tabuni’s group, but any use of these weapons will place a large
number of civilians at risk. It is not the first time the TNI have used
artillery against West Papuan civilians: the Bloody Wamena massacres of
2000 and 2003, as well as the aerial bombardment campaigns in the 1977
and 1984.
Indonesian outrage fuels civil society questions on Papuan motivations for resistance
The killings of the soldiers have generated outrage in Jakarta, with
nationalist politicians calling for cordon and destroy missions in what
human rights observers have said amount to collective civilian
punishment by an occupying force.
Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin – indicted as a war criminal
Indonesian Deputy Defence Minister Lieutenant-General (LG) (Rtd) Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin -
indicted as a war criminal by the UN for his role in East Timor -
on Friday ordered the TNI to conduct heavy “tactical actions” in order
to prevent the shooting from occurring again. “The tactical action
includes to chase, apprehend and destroy,” the deputy minister said here
on Friday. He said the latest shootings by the separatist rebels did
not affect TNI`s strategic policies in Papua. TNI so far did not have a
plan to send more troops to Papua, he added.
However SBY also claimed in an interview with MetroTV that “no
violence” would be used to solve the situation. The situation on the
ground has illustrated that security forces have no interest in making
SBY’s words truthful.
Despite the nationalist rhetoric, there are many in Indonesia who
are seeing this as a wake up call to end Jakarta’s use of state violence
against civilians in Papua as it default policy.
The Indonesian Regional Representatives Council, or DPD, called for
a necessary cessation of military operations to end the prolonged
violence in Indonesia’s easternmost provinces, according to a report in
the Jakarta Post on Wednesday.
The presence of the non-organic personnel from TNI special forces
cause animosity among Papuan groups, who have launched attacks against
them, according to the report. “If Jakarta wants to end violence, the
militaristic approach has to stop, and all non-garrison troops from the
military elite forces must be withdrawn from the two provinces because
their presence and their irregular operations have triggered attacks on
garrison troops and innocent civilians,” DPD deputy chairman Laode Ida
said on Tuesday.
A coalition of Papuan human rights groups urged the National
Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM) to conduct a thorough
investigation into the soldiers’ killings, saying the presence of Komnas
HAM could prevent human rights violations that occurred during TNI
sweep operations after shooting incidents, according to a report in the
Jakarta Globe.
“We encourage law enforcers to be professional in carrying out their
tasks. They must ensure that their attempts to find the perpetrators do
not turn into seeking revenge against all Papuans,” Ferry Marisan from
the Institute for Policy Research and Advocacy (Elsam) said in Jayapura
on Monday.
The TNI has loudly complained in Indonesian media of hurt feelings about the loss of its soldiers, with the
National
Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM) leaders have been forced to
apologise for “insensitive” remarks saying killing soldiers is not a
human rights abuse. But not all observers are showing sympathy for
the loss of the soldiers lives, pointing to the fact that the military
are occupying Papuan land against the wishes of the local people.
“One has to remember that soldiers who were shot were Kopassus
special forces who have been involved in ongoing human rights abuses
right across Puncak Jaya, including village burnings, collective arrests
and punishment, burning of villages, and acts of torture. Many
observers suspect these soldiers were part of units involved in
conducting many OTK (Unknown persons) shootings blamed on West Papuans,”
a long time human rights worker in the highlands told
West Papua Media by email. “These are not innocence, nor babes in the woods; Kopassus are the original wolves in the forest.”
Still, other observers believe the actions point to an assertion of
tribal identity, as a complex motivator behind the declaration of Papuan
sovereignty inherent in the armed resistance against Indonesia’s
militarist policy in the highlands. An Australian church worker who
worked for many years with highland communities in Puncak Jaya made the
observation to
West Papua Media that this was not simply an act
of resistance to Indonesian colonisation, but an assertion of
traditional and indigenous Papuan law and cultural survival against the
onslaught of an occupying colonial army.
“This must be looked at from another perspective that is relevant.
As many indigenous communities including Australian Aboriginal Peoples
and traditional highland Papuan people, observe around the world, if
outsiders came into their sacred lands, they would also feel compelled
at whatever cost to themselves to spear the outsider to compensate
(violations of) their traditional law if they belonged to the clan that
was legally responsible (under customary law) to guard that site,” she
explained.
“Indigenous Law is simply not negotiable on things like that. Things
have only changed in Australia because non-Indigenous systems have for
years now in Australia been locking up those indigenous peoples who have
acted to maintain their law,” the former church worker explained.
“As I understand the TNI despite warnings were acting in a way that broke the Papuans’ traditional laws regarding
adat (Customary
law), and as the TPN are still holding strong to their traditional
laws, so they acted in accordance with the laws they are living by. I
can’t see any difference at that level as Melanesian peoples separated
historically but only a short distance of water. The difference is that
the TPN OPM represent groups that have not yet been overcome by the laws
of a colonising power whereas RI does not recognise the traditional
Papuan customary laws,” she said
A prominent Papuan human rights activist, Yasons Sambon, has reported
that the killings are causing many military families to reconsider
their support for the Indonesian colonial occupation of Papua. In an
interview with the wife of one of the eight soldiers killed at Sinak,
recorded on February 23 after the soldiers funeral in a car by the old
market in Sentani, the widow called for Indonesia to abandon its
occupation of Papua.
Funeral of Sentani based Kopassus officer killed in SInak incident, Feb 24. (supplied)
The wife of an Indonesian soldier from Sentani said in a regretful
tone, “SBY would be better off giving independence to the people of
Papua if it meant our husbands wouldn’t become victims. Our husbands
have been murdered. What will be my fate, and the fate of my children,
now that my husband has been murdered? We want to hold onto our husbands
but they also have a duty to the country. They are murdered and it’s
the women and children who become victims, because if they aren’t at
work, then what will we eat?”
“It’s better if independence is given to the people of Papua so that we can be safe,” she said.
*from the West Papua Media Editorial team, with
additional reporting from stringers in Wamena, Tingginambut, Jayapura,
Nabire and sources in Jakarta.